Rate of Return vs ROI: What Each Number Measures on a Rental
Rate of return vs ROI: a rate is per year, ROI is usually the whole hold. See how to turn a 45% total into an annual number on a $500,000 rental.
By the CashOnCashReturnCalculator.com team
Rate of return vs ROI comes down to one thing: a rate of return is measured per year, while ROI is usually the total earned across the whole time you held the deal. A 24% ROI over five years and an 8% rate of return a year are not two sizes of the same number, they cover different stretches of time.
Get the period wrong and the worse deal can look like the better one.
What does rate of return mean?
A rate of return is profit for one period divided by the money invested, and the period is almost always a year. It answers a single question: what did each dollar earn in twelve months?
Take the simple case. $12,000 of annual cash flow on $150,000 invested is an 8% rate of return. That 8% describes a year, so it lines up against a savings rate, a bond yield or another rental.
Most numbers lenders and brokers quote work this way. Mortgage rates, cap rates, yields and cash on cash return are all per year. The Wikipedia entry on rate of return gives the formal definition, which always carries a time period with it.
A percentage with no period attached is not really a rate yet. The glossary definition of rate of return keeps the period in view.
What does ROI measure, and over how long?
Return on Investment (ROI) is total profit divided by the money invested. There is no time in the formula at all, which is why the same deal gets quoted at very different ROI numbers.
Five years of profit divided by your cash gives a bigger percentage than one year of profit divided by that same cash. Nothing about the property changed. The window did.
So when somebody says a deal did 24% ROI, the useful reply is a question. Over how long, and what counted as profit? Some investors count cash flow only. Others add principal paydown, tax savings and the gain on sale.
Rate of return vs ROI: the difference is the time period
| Rate of return | ROI | |
|---|---|---|
| Formula | one period’s profit / money invested | total profit / money invested |
| Time period | stated, nearly always one year | not in the formula |
| Sounds like | “8% a year” | “45% on the deal” |
| Good for | comparing two investments now | reporting how a deal turned out |
| Fails when | the period is left out | the two hold lengths differ |
There is a second habit worth knowing. ROI usually looks backward at a deal that is finished or modeled to the end, while a rate of return is often quoted forward for the year ahead.
Turning a total ROI into an annual rate of return
Start from the standard example here: a $500,000 rental that rents for $5,200 a month, with $10,000 of rehab, $6,000 of property tax and $2,400 of insurance. At 25% down over 30 years at 7.25%, cash flow runs about $9,460 a year on $150,000 invested, so cash on cash return is about 6.3%.

Hold it five years and collect that cash flow each year. That is $47,300. The loan amortizes too, and the schedule on a $375,000 balance at 7.25% pays down roughly $21,000 of principal across those five years. Leave price changes out, since nobody can promise them.
Total profit of $68,300 on $150,000 invested is a 45.5% ROI over five years. Two ways to make that a yearly figure:
- Simple average: 45.5% divided by 5 is 9.1% a year.
- Compounded: the fifth root of 1.455, minus one, is 7.8% a year. This is the compound annual growth rate.
The gap between 9.1% and 7.8% is the compounding assumption. The compounded figure assumes every dollar of profit stayed in the deal and kept earning. Rental cash flow usually lands in your bank account instead, so the simple average is closer to what actually happened, and the Accounting Rate of Return (ARR) does that same division on purpose.
If you want the version that respects when each dollar arrived, that is Internal Rate of Return (IRR). A simpler cousin, the Payback Period, just asks how many years until the cash invested comes back.
Where cash on cash return sits between the two
Cash on cash return is a rate of return with a narrow numerator. One year of pre-tax cash flow over the cash invested, and nothing else gets in. No principal paydown, no tax effects, no sale price.
That makes it strict and easy to compare. The 6.3% above means the money you put in paid back 6.3 cents per dollar in spendable cash that year. It is always a yearly figure, which is the whole point of the page on whether cash on cash return is annual.
ROI on the same deal comes out higher, because it sweeps in paydown and the sale. The line by line split sits in the guide on cash on cash return vs ROI.
Which number to quote when you compare two rentals
- Ask the period behind every percentage on the table. Per year, or total.
- Convert any total ROI to a yearly figure before you rank anything.
- Write down what is in each numerator. Cash only, or cash plus equity.
- Check the denominator too. Purchase price, cash invested and today’s equity give three different answers.
- Quote a rate when you are choosing between deals, and ROI when you are reporting one that is done.
Back to the two deals at 24% and 8%. If the 24% took five years, it is about 4.4% a year, and the 8% a year deal is the stronger of the two. Same two numbers, opposite conclusion, once the time period is on the table.

Run it on your own deal
The free cash on cash return calculator on the home page takes price, rent, rehab, taxes, insurance and loan terms, then returns a yearly rate you can compare against anything else quoted per year. Start with the $500,000 example, then swap in your own numbers.
Frequently asked questions
Is a 24% ROI better than an 8% rate of return?
Not usually. The 8% is a yearly figure. If the 24% ROI took five years to earn, it works out near 4.4% a year compounded, so the 8% deal is ahead. If the 24% came in a single year, it wins by a wide margin. Ask how long the ROI covers before you rank them.
Does ROI include the mortgage payment and the principal paydown?
It depends who built the number, which is the weak spot in ROI. Most rental ROI figures subtract the full mortgage payment from income, then add the principal portion back as equity gained. Others skip paydown entirely and count cash flow plus the gain on sale. Ask what sits in the numerator before you compare two ROI figures.
Is cash on cash return a rate of return or an ROI?
A rate of return. It covers one year, which makes it comparable to a savings rate or a bond yield. The ROI label gets attached to it loosely, and that is where the confusion starts. Cash on cash return also ignores principal paydown, tax benefits and resale, so it reads lower than most ROI numbers on the same deal.
Why do two people report different ROI numbers for the same rental?
Three reasons, usually. Different holding periods, because a five year total is bigger than a one year total. Different profit definitions, because some count only cash while others add paydown, tax savings and sale proceeds. Different denominators, because cash invested, purchase price and current equity are three separate amounts. Agree on all three and the numbers line up.